Neural Foundations · 2015

Order Matters: Sequence to sequence for sets

Oriol Vinyals, Samy Bengio, Manjunath Kudlur

Demonstrated that the order in which unordered inputs and outputs are fed to sequence models materially changes what they learn, and proposed a read-process-write architecture that encodes sets order-invariantly with attention while searching over output orderings during training.

Editorial record

Plain-language summary

Many problems involve sets rather than sequences, yet models were trained by picking an arbitrary order. The authors show experimentally that this arbitrary choice can swing results, for example when sorting numbers or parsing. They introduce a set encoder that reads all elements, processes them with attention over a memory for several steps, and writes outputs with a pointer network. The paper is an early, concrete argument that inductive biases about ordering and permutation invariance matter, a theme that reappears in graph networks and in positional encodings for transformers.

Source record

Provenance

Record ID
P-673
Record created
2026-09-26
Last reviewed
2026-09-26
Record version
1

Citation caveat: Citation metadata is approximate and marked unverified in the source dataset.